Thesis Statement: Although Kenneth Branagh and David Tennant are both trying to reach the same goals of creating a film based on Shakespeare’s play Hamlet they have different ways of portraying Hamlets character in each scene.
Paragraph 1 :
Compare: David Tennant, who portrays Hamlet, appears to be frightened and curious about the reason why his father’s ghost has appeared. It was easy to see that by the way Hamlets faced had frowned the he was confused about what he should do when he was being asked by his father’s ghost to follow. But you knew that he wanted to see what King Hamlet was trying to show him because there was an immediate follow afterwards. It’s like he wants to follow but then again he thinks it would be a bad idea. The way he responds to the ghost is with a shaky, low tone of voice.
Contrast: David Tennant portrayed Hamlet to be more afraid about what was going on. By him talking in a low voice the entire time and not showing any type of anger made him seem more concerned, showing a more sympathetic side of him. He also had long pauses in between giving hints that he was thinking about his father. The way Tennant reacted toward his father’s murder was in a more compassionate way than he was portrayed in Kenneth Branghs’movie.
Compare: Hamlet not knowing what was going on at the grace site seemed like it was a buildup of curiosity. Hearing from the gravedigger who skull one have belong to Hamlet began to examine it in remembrance of Yorick. Holding the skull closer to his face made it shocking for him to look at not knowing whose skull it was. Talking about all the times the both of them had shared together with Horatio made remember all he knew about Yaric.
Compare: As Kenneth Branagh, who portrays Hamlet, speaks to his father his facial expressions are portrayed to be the same way that David Tennant portrayed them to be as well. He was very spooked about what had been coming upon to him. Due to him being scared his voice was shaky as well. Because he didn’t know what his father’s purpose was of being there he was very willing to find out.
Contrast: Kenneth Branagh portrayed Hamlet to be more confident of his characters role. Hamlet looking in the mirror makes his character more powerful and you are able to tell how angry he really is. Looking in the mirror also make himself believe what he really is capable of doing. The knife also shows how angry he is about his father’s death kind of referring to how he wants to kill who ever had killed his father.
Compare: Hamlet was more curious because he had not known who the skull had belonged to. You can tell he was curious because he asked the gravedigger questions. Finally learning that the skull had been Yoricks, Hamlet tells Horatio about the experience he had had with him before his death. Looking at the skull and hearing the name almost brought back an automatic remembrance of him. Also realizing that all men would end up turning to dust similar to Yorick. Looking at Branaghs face you see mixed emotions of curiosity and confusion.
Act 1 Scene 4 Comparison: Kenneth Branagh and David Tennant both had similar interpretations of Hamlet to Shakespeare. In this scene Hamlet had very wanted to follow his father’s ghost but at the same time he was confused because Horatio and Marcellus were telling him to do the opposite. In the play Shakespeare portrayed Hamlet to be confused and not sure of what he was seeing. In the films he was the same way acting confused as well. But he knew what he wanted to do that’s why he followed the ghost as it disappeared in the darkness.
Act 3 Scene 1 Comparison: David Tennant’s portrayal to Hamlet was similar to Shakespeare because he was more compassionate and showed more sympathy towards his father’s death. As to where Kenneth Branagh portrayal to Hamlet was opposite to Shakespeare due to him showing more anger than sympathy throughout the scene. Shakespeare’s portrayal of Hamlet in this scene was calm but the wording provided showed that he was upset about the death of his father.
Act 5 Scene 1 Comparison: Both of the directors succeeded in having identical portrayals to Hamlet as Shakespeare. Kenneth Branagh and David Tennant both portrayed Hamlet to have memories and confusion about Yoricks skull. Asking the gravedigger questions showed the confusion that he was faced with. Realizing that all men would end up dead similar to Yorick brought a shocked look to Hamlets faced. Shakespeare portrayed Hamlet to be confused, shocked and having mixed emotions about seeing the skull and realizing who it had belong to.